Nunavut MLAs question premier on performance bonus formula
Peter Mackey, ex-head of Qulliq Energy, tops bonus list
Arviat South MLA Joe Savikataaq wants more transparency around how and why deputy ministers, and the heads of Crown corporations, get paid in performance bonuses.
At the Nunavut legislature in Iqaluit May 28, Savikataaq asked Premier Peter Taptuna about a recently tabled document that outlines how much the government workers received in bonus and merit payments.
In it, Savikataaq pointed out the Government of Nunavut paid out just over $300,000 in bonuses to the government workers in the 2012-13 fiscal year.
Those workers include:
* Kathleen Okpik — $26,353 bonus;
• Christian D’Arcy — $24,438 bonus;
• Peter Ma — $22,219 bonus;
• Joe Adla Kunuk — $21,529 bonus;
• Norman Tarnow — $21,403 bonus;
• Roy Green — $20,728 bonus;
• Daniel Vandermeulen — $20,057 bonus;
• Simon Awa — $19,666 bonus;
• David Akeeagok — $16,092 bonus, $8,699 merit pay;
• Robert Long — $15,515 bonus, $4,433 merit pay;
• Aluki Rojas — $9,344 bonus; and,
• Kathleen Lausman — $3,366 bonus.
Crown corporation heads:
• Qulliq Energy Corp. president Peter Mackey — $40,000 bonus;
• Nunavut Arctic College president Michael Shouldice — $21,235 bonus;
• Nunavut Housing Corp. president Alain Barriault — $16,907 bonus, $4,449 merit pay; and,
• Nunavut Business Credit Corp. chief executive officer Sherri Rowe — $8,252 bonus.
In the past three fiscal years, deputy ministers and heads of Crown corporations received a total of $935,991 in bonuses.
The largest performance bonus went to ousted QEC president Peter Mackey with $40,000 in 2012-13. In 2011-12 his bonuses amounted to $43,967, and in 2010-11, they came to $25,600.
“Nunavummiut need to have confidence that spending of this nature is justified,” Savikataaq said during question period. He asked the premier if there’s a methodology to the payments.
Taptuna said there is a methodology, based on pay scale.
“There is a limit to the bonus and merit pay,” Taptuna said.
Taptuna said the compensations help retain and attract government workers, and that the GN has no plans to change the method at this time.
“We’re at competition with the rest of the nation,” Taptuna said. “It’s very difficult to compete with bigger jurisdictions like [the Northwest Territories], Yukon and the provinces.”
The tabled document only surfaced after Tununiq MLA Joe Enook submitted a written question to the Nunavut legislature March 10 about who received bonuses, and how much.
Savikataaq said this type of document should be readily available and public information. It’s tabled in other jurisdictions on an annual basis — so why not Nunavut?
Taptuna largely agreed with Savikataaq.
“These are public funds. And to be open and transparent, I can’t see why we should not be able to do that with our deputy heads and our senior personnel,” Taptuna said.
“It’s one of those things that most jurisdictions are doing and it’s one of those things that I want to see happening,” he said.
Speaking with media after question period, Savikataaq said he was “satisfied” with Taptuna’s answer.
“I just wanted to know how it was calculated because the results were given out but there was no way of figuring out why they got the amount they got,” Savikataaq said. “Like, it’s not consistent across the board.”